Radical Hope or the Moral Imperative of Images in the Work of Susan Sontag Jean-Luc Godard


  • Idit Alphandary Interdisciplinary Program of the Arts and NCJW Women and Gender Studies Program, Tel Aviv University, Israel




Susan Sontag, Jean-Luc Godard, Jacques Derrida, Film studies, hope, testimony, the Bosnian war


In the films For Ever Mozart, In Praise of Love and I Salute You Sarajevo, Go-dard’s images introduce radical hope to the world. I will demonstrate that this hope represents an ethical posture in the world; it is identical to goodness. Radical hope is grounded in the victim’s witnessing, internalizing and remembering catastrophe, while at the same time holding onto the belief that a variation of the self will survive the disaster.

In The Gift of Death, Jacques Derrida argues that choosing to belong to the disaster is equivalent to giving the pure gift, or to goodness itself, and that it suggests a new form of responsibility for one’s life, as well as a new form of death. For Derrida, internalizing catastrophe is identical to death—a death that surpasses one’s means of giving. Such death can be reciprocated only by reinstating goodness or the law in the victim’s or the giver’s existence.

The relation of survival to the gift of death—also a gift of life—challenges us to rethink our understanding of the act of witnessing. This relation also adds nuance to our appreciation of the intellectual, emotional and mental affects of the survival of the victim and the testimony and silence of the witness, all of which are important in my analysis of radical hope. On the one hand, the (future) testimony of the witness inhabits the victim or the ravaged self (now), on the other hand, testimony is not contemporaneous with the shattered ego. This means that testimony is anterior to the self or that the self that survives the disaster has yet to come into existence through making testimony material. Testimony thus exists before and beyond disaster merely as an ethical posture—a “putting-oneself-to-death or offering-one’s-death, that is, one’s life, in the ethical dimension of sacrifice,” in the words of Derrida. The witness is identical to the victim whose survival will include an unknown, surprising testimony or an event of witnessing. The testimony discloses the birth or revelation of a new self. And yet this new self survives through assuming the position of the witness even while s/he is purely the victim of catastrophe, being put to death owning the “kiss of death.”


Agamben, Giorgio (2002): Remnants of Auschwitz: the Witness and the Archive (trans): Daniel Heller-Roazen, New York: Zone Books.

Badiou, Alain (2003): Saint Paul: The Foundation of Universalism. Trans., Ray Brassier. Stanford: Stanford UP, 93-97.

Beauvoir De, Simone (1995): "Preface;" Lanzmann, Claude: Shoa, New York: De Capo Press.

Benjamin, Walter (1968): "The Storyteller”, Harry Zohn (trans): Illuminations, New York: Schocken Books.

Blanchot, Maurice (1995): "The Exigency of Return (1969)”, Michael Holland (ed): The Blanchot Reader, Oxford and Cambridge: Blackwell, 279-289.

Cavell, Stanley (1996): "Naughty Orators: Negation of Voice in Gaslight”, Stanley, Cavell: Contesting Tears: The Hollywood Melodrama of the Unknown Woman, Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 47 – 78.

Cavell, Stanley (1994): In Quest of the Ordinary: Lines of Skepticism and Romanticism, Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

Cavell, Stanley (1979): The World Viewed: Reflections on the Ontology of Film, Cambridge Mass: Harvard University Press.

Derrida, Jacques (1995): The Gift of Death, David Willis (trans): Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

Felstiner, John (1995): Paul Celan Poet, Survivor, Jew, New Haven: Yale University Press.

Gogdard, Jean-Luc and Miéville, Anne-Marie (2006): Je Vous Salue, Sarajevo, France.

Godard (2001): Eloge de L’Amour, Switzerland.

Godard. (1996): For Ever Mozart (1996): Switzerland and France.

Laub, Dori (1992): "Bearing Witness or the Vicissitudes of Listening”, Shoshana Felman and Dori Laub (eds): Testimony. New York: Routledge, 57-74.

Lear, Jonathan (2006): Radical Hope: Ethics in the Face of Cultural Devastation, Cambridge, Massachusetts: Harvard University Press.

Sontag, Susan (2003): Reading the Pain of Others, New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux.

Sontag, Susan. (1961): "Godard’s Vivre Sa Vie”, Susan Sontag, Against Interpretation and Other Essays, New York: Delta, 196-208.

Toubiana, Serge (1996): "Le bel héros fatal”, Cahiers du cinéma, 508, 12.




How to Cite

Alphandary, I. (2009) “Radical Hope or the Moral Imperative of Images in the Work of Susan Sontag Jean-Luc Godard”, Culture Unbound, 1(2), pp. 487–501. doi: 10.3384/cu.2000.1525.09128487.