Reading Rural Consumption Practices for Difference: Bolt-holes, Castles and Life-rafts

Keith Halfacree

doi:10.3384/cu.2000.1525.10214241

Authors

Keith Halfacree Human Geography, Swansea University, Wales, Great Britain

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.3384/cu.2000.1525.10214241

Keywords:

Rural, reading for difference, representations, consumption practices, everyday life, social movement

Abstract

Based mostly on evidence from the UK, this paper challenges the rural’s usual association with predominantly conservative politics and practices. It advocates showing awareness of ambiguity in how representations, and specifically in this paper rural representations, and their numerous associated consumption practices are interpreted. A focus is given on the possibility of interpreting these practiced rural representations in the context of responses to the negative features within everyday life identified by writers such as Lefebvre. Drawing specifically on the “postmodern Marxism” of Gibson-Graham (2006), and particularly beginning to deploy what they term “reading for difference rather than dominance”, the paper introduces three “styles” of consuming the rural. These are expressed via the metaphors of bolt-hole, castle and life-raft, and it is argued that they can be read as expressing critique of urban everyday life. In the concluding section, the lessons learned from reading rural consumption practices for difference in this way are brought together to suggest that not only can the rural today be regarded as an active “heterotopia” but that this alternative status could be used to underpin an urban-focused social movement for reclamation of what Lefebvre termed “every-day life”.

References

Ambrose, Peter (1992): “The Rural/Urban Fringe as Battleground”, Brian Short (ed.): The English Rural Community, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 175–194.

Bauman, Zygmunt (1992): Intimations of Postmodernity, London: Routledge.

Bell, David (1997): “Anti-idyll. Rural horror”, Paul Cloke & Jo Little (eds): Contested Countryside Cultures, London: Routledge, 94–108.

Bendix, Regina & Löfgren, Orvar (2008): “Double homes, double lives?”, Ethnologia Europaea 37:1/2, 7–15.

Bunce, Michael (1994): The Countryside Ideal, London: Routledge.

Bunce, Michael (2003): “Reproducing Rural Idylls”, Paul Cloke (ed.): Country Visions, Harlow: Pearson, 14–30.

CAT [Centre for Alternative Technology] (2009): Homepage at: www.cat.org.uk (accessed 01/2010).

Clarke, David (2003): The Consumer Society and the Postmodern City, London: Routledge. [Read this Article]

Cloke, Paul (1992): “‘The Countryside’: Development, Conservation and an Increasingly Marketable Commodity”, Paul Cloke (ed.): Policy and Change in Thatcher’s Britain, Oxford: Pergamon, 269–295.

Cloke, Paul (ed.) (2003): Country Visions, Harlow: Pearson.

Cloke, Paul, Terry Marsden & Patrick Mooney (2006) (eds): Handbook of Rural Studies, London: Sage.

Conradson, David & Alan Latham (2005): “Transnational Urbanism: Attending to Everyday Practices and Mobilities”, Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies, 31, 227–335. [Read this Article]

Copp, James (1972): “Rural Sociology and Rural Development”, Rural Sociology, 37, 515–533.

Coppock, John Terrence (ed.) (1977): Second Homes: Curse or Blessing?, Oxford: Pergamon.

Craze, Richard (2004): Out of Your Townie Mind, Devon: White Ladder Press.

Dale, Tony (2001): “A Conversation with Vashti Bunyan”, Terrascope Online, March, at: www.terrascope.co.uk (accessed 01/10).

Del Casino, Vincent. & Stephen Hanna (2006): “Beyond the ’Binaries’: A Methodological Intervention for Interrogating Maps as Representational Practices”, ACME 4, 34–56.

Edensor, Tim (2000): “Walking in the British Countryside”, Body and Society, 6, 81–106. [Read this Article]

Elms, Robert (2001): “Why I Hate the Countryside”, Guardian 28th April, http://www.guardian.co.uk/theguardian/2001/apr/28/weekend7.weekend2 (accessed 01/10).

Eyles, John (1989): “The Geography of Everyday Life”, Derek Gregory & Rex Walford (eds): Horizons in Human Geography, Basingstoke: Macmillan, 102–117.

Fairlie, Simon (2001): The Dowry. A Left Wing Defence of Rural England, South Petherton, Somerset: Chapter 7 Publications.

Falk, Ian & Sue Kilpatrick (2000): “What is Social Capital? A Study of Interaction in a Rural Community”, Sociologia Ruralis 40, 87–110. [Read this Article]

Foucault, Michel (1986): “Of Other Spaces”, Diacritics 16, 22–27. [Read this Article]

Gallent, Nick (2007): “Second Homes, Community and a Hierarchy of Dwelling”, Area 39, 97–106. [Read this Article]

Gardiner, Michael (2000): Critiques of Everyday Life, London: Routledge.

Gardiner, Michael (2006): “Everyday Knowledge”, Theory, Culture and Society 23, 205–207. [Read this Article]

Garvey, Pauline (2008): “The Norwegian Country Cabin and Functionalism: A Tale of two Modernities”, Social Anthropology / Anthropologie Sociale 16, 203–220.

Gibson-Graham, Julie Katherine (1996): The End of Capitalism (as we knew it), Oxford: Blackwell.

Gibson-Graham, Julie Katherine (2006): A Postcapitalist Politics, London: University of Minnesota Press.

Giddens, Anthony (1984): The Constitution of Society, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Goodwin, Mark (2006): “Regulating Rurality? Rural Studies and the Regulation Approach”, Paul Cloke, Terry Marsden & Patrick Mooney (eds): Handbook of Rural Studies, London: Sage, 304–316.

Gosnell, Hannah & Jesse Abrams (2009): “Amenity Migration: Diverse Conceptualizations of Drivers, Socioeconomic Dimensions, and Emerging Challenges”, GeoJournal, http://www.springerlink.com/content/9l40n2843572mm05/fulltext.pdf (accessed 03/2010).

Guardian (2004): “Urbanites Heading to the Hills in Droves”, 22nd June.

Halfacree, Keith (1993): “Locality and Social Representation: Space, Discourse and Alternative Definitions of the Rural”, Journal of Rural Studies, 9, 23–37. [Read this Article]

Halfacree, Keith (1994): “The Importance of ‘the Rural’ in the Constitution of Counterurbanization: Evidence from England in the 1980s”, Sociologia Ruralis, 34, 164–189. [Read this Article]

Halfacree, Keith (1997): “Contrasting Roles for the Post-productivist Countryside: A Post-modern Perspective on Counterurbanisation”, Paul Cloke & Jo Little (eds): Contested Countryside Cultures, London: Routledge, 70–93.

Halfacree, Keith (2003): “Landscapes of Rurality: Rural Others / Other Rurals”, Iain Roberston & Penny Richards (eds): Studying Cultural Landscapes, London: Arnold, 141–169.

Halfacree, Keith (2006a): “Rural Space: Constructing a Three-fold Architecture”, Paul Cloke, Terry Marsden & Patrick Mooney (eds): Handbook of Rural Studies, London: Sage, 44–62.

Halfacree, Keith (2006b): “From Dropping out to Leading on? British Counter-cultural Back-to-the-land in a Changing Rurality”, Progress in Human Geography, 30, 309–336. [Read this Article]

Halfacree, Keith (2007a): “Still Surprises in Store. Revisiting the Ordinary in Rural Geography”, Documents d’Anàlisi Geogràfica, 50, 87–103.

Halfacree, Keith (2007b): “Trial by Space for a ‘Radical Rural’: Introducing Alternative Localities, Representations and Lives”, Journal of Rural Studies, 23, 125–141. [Read this Article]

Halfacree, Keith (2008): “To Revitalise Counterurbanisation Research? Recognising an International and Fuller Picture”, Population, Space and Place, 14, 479–495. [Read this Article]

Halfacree, Keith (2009): “‘Glow Worms Show the Path we Have to Tread’: the Counterurbanisation of Vashti Bunyan”, Social and Cultural Geography, 10, 771–789. [Read this Article]

Halfacree, Keith (forthcoming a): “Heterolocal Identities?: Counter-urbanisation, Second Homes and Rural Consumption in the era of Mobilities”, Population, Space and Place.

Halfacree, Keith (forthcoming b): “‘Alternative’ Communities in Rural Wales”, Paul Milbourne (ed.): Geographies of Rural Wales, Cardiff: University of Wales Press.

Halfacree, Keith (forthcoming c): “Interpreting Rurality in the 21st Century: From Effacement to (Re-):Invention”, László Kulcsár & Katherine Curtis (eds): International Handbook of Rural Demography, New York: Springer.

Hall, Colin & Dieter Müller (eds) (2004a): Tourism, Mobility and Second Homes, Clevedon: Channel View Publications.

Hall, Colin & Dieter Müller (2004b): “Introduction: Second Homes, Curse or Blessing? Revisited”, Colin Hall & Dieter Müller (eds): Tourism, Mobility and Second Homes, Clevedon: Channel View Publications, 3–14.

Hanna, Stephen, Vincent Del Casino, Casey Selden & Benjamin Hite (2004): “Representation as Work in ‘America’s Most Historic City’”, Social and Cultural Geography, 5, 459–481. [Read this Article]

Hedgepeth, William (1971): “The Commune Way Keeps Spreading Because Maybe it’ll be Different Here”, Look Magazine, 35, 63–70.

Hetherington, Kevin (2000): New Age Travellers, London: Cassell.

Hewison, Robert (1987): The Heritage Industry, London: Methuen.

Hoggart, Keith (1990): “Let’s do Away with Rural”, Journal of Rural Studies, 6, 245–257. [Read this Article]

Holloway, John (2002): Change the World Without Taking Power, London: Pluto.

Hopkins, Jeffrey (1998): “Signs of the Post-rural: Marketing Myths of a Symbolic Countryside”, Geografiska Annaler B, 80, 65–81. [Read this Article]

Howkins, Alun (2003): The Death of Rural England, London: Routledge.

Kaltenborn, Bjørn (1998): “The Alternative Home: Motives of Recreation Home Use”, Norsk Geografisk Tidsskrift, 52, 121–134. [Read this Article]

Lash, Scott & Joahn Urry (1994): Economies of Signs and Space, London: Sage.

Leary, Timothy (1983): Flashbacks, New York: Putnam.

Lefebvre, Henri (1984/1968): Everyday Life in the Modern World, New Brunswick: Transaction Publishers.

Lefebvre, Henri (1991/1958): Critique of Everyday Life, Volume 1, London: Verso.

Lefebvre, Henri (1991/1974): The Production of Space, Oxford: Blackwell.

Lefebvre, Henri (1996): Writings on Cities, Oxford: Blackwell.

Lowe, Philip, Jonathan Murdoch & Graham Cox (1995): “A Civilised Retreat? Anti-urbanism, Rurality and the Making of an Anglo-centric Culture”, Patsy Healey, Stuart Cameron, Simin Davoudi, Stephen Graham & Ali Madani-Pour (eds): Managing Cities, Chichester: Wiley, 63–82.

Lucas, Caroline (2002): “Relocalising the Global Food Economy”, BBC Lecture, Cardiff University, May, available at:
http://www.carolinelucasmep.org.uk/speeches/Relocalisingfood010502.htm.

Maffesoli, Michael (1987): “Sociality as Legitimation of Sociological Method”, Current Sociology, 35, 69–87. [Read this Article]

Marsden, Terry (1999): “Rural Futures: The Consumption Countryside and its Regulation”, Sociologia Ruralis, 39, 501–520. [Read this Article]

McIntyre, Norman, Daniel Williams & Kevin McHugh (2006): “Multiple Dwelling: Prospect and Retrospect”, Norman McIntyre, Daniel Williams & Kevin McHugh (eds): Multiple Dwelling and Tourism. Negotiating Place, Home and Identity, Wallingford: CABI, 313–322.

Miller, Daniel (1987): Material Culture and Mass Consumption, Oxford: Blackwell.

Murdoch, Jonathan & Graham Day (1998): “Middle Class Mobility, Rural Communities and the Politics of Exclusion”, Paul Boyle & Kieth Halfacree (eds): Migration into Rural Areas. Theories and Issues, Chichester: Wiley, 186–199.

Murdoch, Jonathan & Terry Marsden (1994): Reconstituting Rurality, London: UCL Press.

Murdoch, Jonathan, Philip Lowe, Neil Ward & Terry Marsden (2003): The Differentiated Countryside, London: Routledge.

Neal, Sarah & Sue Walters (2007): “‘You Can Get Away with Loads Because There’s no One Here’: Discourses of Regulation and Non-regulation in English Rural Spaces”, Geoforum, 38, 252–263. [Read this Article]

Nelson, Elizabeth (1989): The British Counter-culture, 1966–73. A Study of the Underground Press, Basingstoke: Macmillan.

Overvåg, Kjell (2009): Second Homes in Eastern Norway, Trondheim: Norwegian University of Science and Technology, Doctoral Theses at NTNU 238.

Phillips, Martin, Rob Fish & Jennifer Agg (2001): “Putting Together Ruralities: Towards a Symbolic Analysis of Rurality in the British Mass Media”, Journal of Rural Studies, 17, 1–28. [Read this Article]

Quinn, Bernadette (2004): “Dwelling Through Multiple Places: a Case Study of Second Home Ownership in Ireland”, Colin Hall & Dieter Müller (eds): Tourism, Mobility and Second Homes, Clevedon: Channel View Publications, 113–129.

Rigby, Andrew (1974): Alternative Realities, London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.

Rivers, Patrick (1978): Living on a Little Land, London: Turnstone Books.

Savage, Mike, James Barlow, Peter Dickens & Tony Fielding (1992): Property, Bureaucracy and Culture, London: Routledge.

Savage, Mike, Alan Warde & Kevin Ward (2003): Urban Sociology, Capitalism and Modernity, 2nd edition, Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.

Sheller, Mimi & John Urry (2006): “The New Mobilities Paradigm”, Environment and Planning A, 38, 207–226. [Read this Article]

Short, John (1991): Imagined Country, London: Routledge.

Short, John, Stephen Fleming & Stephen Witt (1986): Housebuilding, Planning and Community Action, London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.

Shucksmith, Mark (1983): “Second Homes – A Framework for Policy”, Town Planning Review, 54, 174–193.

Stewart, Kathleen (1996): A Space on the Side of the Road: Cultural Poetics in an ”Other” America, Princeton: Princeton University Press.

Swyngedouw, Eric & Maria Kaïka (2000): “The Environment of the City… or the Urbanization of Nature”, Gary Bridge & Sophie Watson (eds): A Companion to the City, Oxford: Blackwell, 567–580.

Thrift, Nigel (2003): “Still Life in Nearly Present Time: The Object of Nature”, Paul Cloke (ed.): Country Visions, Harlow: Pearson, 308–331.

Thrift, Nigel (2005): “But Malice Aforethought: Cities and the Natural History of Hatred”, Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, 30, 133–150. [Read this Article]

Van Dam, Frank, Saskia Heins & Berein Elbersen (2002): “Lay Discourses of the Rural and Stated and Revealed Preferences for Rural Living. Some Evidence of the Existence of a Rural Idyll in the Netherlands”, Journal of Rural Studies, 18, 461–476. [Read this Article]

Vepsäläinen, Mia & Kati Pitkänen (forthcoming): “Second Home Countryside. Representations of the Rural in Finnish Popular Discourses”, Journal of Rural Studies.

Wallace, Anne (1993): Walking, Literature, and English Culture, Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Williams, Raymond (1973): The Country and the City, London: Chatto and Windus.

Winchester, Hilary & Matthew Rofe (2005): “Christmas in the ‘Valley of Praise’: Intersections of the Rural Idyll, Heritage and Community in Lobethal, South Australia”, Journal of Rural Studies, 21, 265–279. [Read this Article]

Woods, Michael (2005): Contesting Rurality. Politics in the British Countryside, Aldershot: Ashgate.

Woods, Michael (2003): “Deconstructing Rural Protest: The Emergence of a New Social Movement”, Journal of Rural Studies, 19, 309–325. [Read this Article]

Wright, Patrick (1985): On Living in an Old Country, London: Verso.

Young, Jock (1973): “The Hippie Solution: An Essay in the Politics of Leisure”, Ian Taylor & Laurie Taylor (eds): Politics and Deviance, Harmondsworth: Penguin, 182–208.

Zelinsky, Wilbur & Barret Lee (1998): “Heterolocalism: An Alternative Model of the Sociospatial Behaviour of Immigrant Ethnic Communities”, International Journal of Population Geography, 4, 281–298. [Read this Article]

Zicklin, Gilbert (1983): Countercultural Communes, London: Greenwood Press.